Most learning has always come easy for me. In school (too many years ago to count), I got straight “A’s” and graduated at the top of my class – co-valedictorian – there were eight of us.
In Bible studies, I’ve always grasped Biblical concepts with relative ease, and have to remember that not everyone understands things as quickly. I hate repetition, most of the time, because I usually “got it” the first time around.
Not so with writing. Well, let me rephrase that. In my younger years writing came easily to me – especially poetry. But I went through a period of burying the gift, and I wonder if that’s why it’s taken me so much longer to grasp all the little nuances of the craft.
Or maybe I just picked a tough career.
I’ve heard it said that crafting a novel (and doing it well) is as difficult as learning to be a surgeon. Most people wouldn’t see it that way because many people view writing as something that anyone can do. Like what’s so hard about it anyway?
Well, the hardest thing is the subjectivity of it all. That became clear to me after receiving my scores and critiques back from a contest I recently entered. After reading them all over, I realized something. Add these four critiques to the four that I had before the contest from my published critique partners and then a critique I paid for by an author in the field I’m writing in, and I’ve had these chapters looked at by nine published authors!
And everyone had a different take on them. The comments were different, many positive, few negative. Only one had more bad than good to say. But it’s funny how the negatives are the ones we focus on.
And I do focus on them because I’m alwasys trying to improve. The goal, after all, is to find a publisher that will love my work. So I take criticism seriously.
But today, after some of the negative comments I’ve received, and the confusion I’ve felt over so many diverse comments from so many published friends and acquaintances, I’ve felt like a “C” student in a world where only “A+” authors make it. That isn’t easy for someone who has always been in the top of her class at school or at church. Especially when I long to excel at this. I don’t think I’ve worked harder at anything else in my life.
Some authors tell me I’m closer than I think. Maybe I only feel like a “C” student. Maybe I’m more like a “B” going on an “A”. Wouldn’t that be nice?
In any case, I’ve learned something.
1. Don’t take every criticism to heart. They are only opinions after all.
2. Subjective means just that – everyone has different tastes in books.
3. Pray. God’s opinion matters most.
It sure would be nice to be an “A” student though. Maybe one of these days.